TAHbKA
Cats and garlic lover
- Messages
- 22,015
So instead of Zhulin it will be Durnev or Petukhov. Have you heard their last names? There you go.
It's the same dumb logic that let Valieva skate at the 2022 Olympics. That not being able to go to the Olympics would irreparably harm her because it's the pinnacle of the sport.I don't understand the ISU decision. I can't imagine subjecting Shmuratko or Ukrainian coaches to share a space with someone like Zhulin. What have chamged? Have the war stopped? If not - what is the difference now?
The faith some of you have that the ISU is going to take this criteria seriously is touching.Zhulin's never going to be approved as a coach at the Olympics under these restrictions. Neither will Plushenko. Both of them have been far too supportive of the war.
I did feel a bit nauseous reading this thread yesterday.I love figure skating, but this ISU decision makes me puke.
So instead of Zhulin it will be Durnev or Petukhov. Have you heard their last names? There you go.
It’s not like Russia can just name people. There are going to be screeners investigating every aspect of the persons life. And the rules are so broad. Was this years Russian nationals sponsored by companies sanctioned for war involvement? Yes. That will easily lead to everyone involved in any aspect of this years Nationals out.So instead of Zhulin it will be Durnev or Petukhov. Have you heard their last names? There you go.
Teams | ||
---|---|---|
Team name | Event | Members |
Not Gonna Get Us (Kamila Valieva) | Men Women Pairs Ice Dance* | Dmitri Aliev, Makar Ignatov, Andrei Mozalev, Evgeni Semenenko Ksenia Gushchina [a], Sofia Muravieva, Sofia Samodelkina, Elizaveta Tuktamysheva, Anastasia Zinina [a] Aleksandra Boikova / Dmitrii Kozlovskii, Yasmina Kadyrova / Valerii Kolesov Sofia Tyutyunina / Andrei Bagin, Elizaveta Shanaeva / Pavel Drozd |
Red Machine (Alina Zagitova) | Men Women Pairs Ice Dance* | Petr Gumennik, Artem Kovalev, Gleb Lutfullin, Alexander Samarin Sofia Akateva, Alina Gorbacheva, Adeliia Petrosian, Veronika Yametova Anastasia Mishina / Aleksandr Galliamov, Evgenia Tarasova / Vladimir Morozov Elizaveta Khudaiberdieva / Egor Bazin, Vasilisa Kaganovskaia / Valeriy Angelopol |
v | Anastasia Mishina/Aleksandr Galliamov | Aleksandra Stepanova/Ivan Bukin | |
Alisa Dvoeglazova | Lev Lazarev | Aleksandra Boikova/Dmitri Kozlovski | Elizaveta Khudaiberdieva/Egor Bazin |
Lidiia Pleskacheva | Ivan Ramzenkov | Yulia Artemieva/Aleksei Bryukhanov | Irina Khavronina/Devid Narizhny |
Adeliia Petrosian | Evgeni Semenenko | Ekaterina Chikmareva/Matvei Yanchenkov | Ekaterina Mironova/Evgeni Ustenko |
Ksenia Sinitsyna | Mark Kondratiuk | Natalia Khabibullina/Ilya Knyazhuk | Sofia Leontieva/Daniil Gorelkin |
Anna Frolova | Vladislav Dikidzhi | Elizaveta Osokina/Artem Gritsaenko | Sofia Shevchenko/Andrei Ezhlov |
Alina Gorbacheva | Dmitri Aliev | ||
Veronika Yametova | Roman Savosin | ||
Daria Sadkova | Daniil Samsonov | ||
Sofia Muravieva | Petr Gumennik | ||
Maria Agaeva | Matvei Vetlugin | ||
Ksenia Gushchina | Alexander Samarin |
Not if they are going to be there with a Russian skaterRussian coaches are generally allowed at ISU competitions if they can get the visas. It's the Russian skaters that are banned, not the coaches. Whether this should be so is another matter.
I was absolutely disgusted to read this. No Russian skater should be allowed to set foot on internationally competitive ice again until such time as Russia is completely gone from Ukraine and the country is rebuilt. And if that means generations of Russian skaters not getting to compete, so be it.
I don't know. At present I can only speak to motorsport, and Russian drivers must sign a declaration that they denounce Putin's actions in Ukraine before they can compete in the big series. Tellingly, I can't think of any Russian driver in any major series.Can I ask what’s going on with other sports? And also the winter Olympics? What about the skiers and the luge and the hockey players and all that? Are they doing the same thing with the other sports as well?
When i quickly turned on swimming worlds, the Russians were competing as AINs including in "Team" relays. I have no idea what the conditions for them being able to compete was.Can I ask what’s going on with other sports? And also the winter Olympics? What about the skiers and the luge and the hockey players and all that? Are they doing the same thing with the other sports as well?
just short course swimming worlds! Not the full one. But still isu has banned multiple entrants so this can’t be the case. Isu has much different rulesWhen i quickly turned on swimming worlds, the Russians were competing as AINs including in "Team" relays. I have no idea what the conditions for them being able to compete was.
LolI was absolutely disgusted to read this. No Russian skater should be allowed to set foot on internationally competitive ice again until such time as Russia is completely gone from Ukraine and the country is rebuilt. And if that means generations of Russian skaters not getting to compete, so be it.
I was absolutely disgusted to read this. No Russian skater should be allowed to set foot on internationally competitive ice again until such time as Russia is completely gone from Ukraine and the country is rebuilt. And if that means generations of Russian skaters not getting to compete, so bW
I imagine any Russian driver who would sign such a statement would have to stay away from windows indefinitely.I don't know. At present I can only speak to motorsport, and Russian drivers must sign a declaration that they denounce Putin's actions in Ukraine before they can compete in the big series. Tellingly, I can't think of any Russian driver in any major series.
Maybe some Russian F1 drivers live completely elsewhere, without any ties to Russia?I imagine any Russian driver who would sign such a statement would have to stay away from windows indefinitely.
Not sure if it can be posted here. But please read the comments from ex-skaters, US officials, skating agent, ex-Ukrainian skating federation president about participating in Russian skating shows. Heartbreaking.The comments on vadym kolesniks instagram post are absolutely disgusting. The lack of empathy for Russian fans to comment that shit when Russia has literally blown up not only his home rink but his brothers home.
It's her personal decision, and one i am not sure she didn't take lightly judging from this video. For her sake, I would hope she is safe while she is there...Not sure if it can be posted here. But please read the comments from ex-skaters, US officials, skating agent, ex-Ukrainian skating federation president about participating in Russian skating shows. Heartbreaking.
www.facebook.com
Are you talking about comments on Naomi's FB? (glad I can't see them, if so) Fortunately she turned off the comments on her YT video.... please read the comments from ex-skaters, US officials, skating agent, ex-Ukrainian skating federation president about participating in Russian skating shows. Heartbreaking.
Starr Andrews even got trolled for posting her support for Vadym (and she didn't take the bait, good for her).The comments on vadym kolesniks instagram post are absolutely disgusting. The lack of empathy for Russian fans to comment that shit when Russia has literally blown up not only his home rink but his brothers home.
Copying out Vadym's full post:Kolesnik has a full-out post now with photos of the offenders.
![]()
vadymkolesnik on Instagram: "I would like to express my concern and to advocate for the exclusion of Russia from the Olympic qualifying series. This request is grounded in two significant issues: the ongoing war in Ukraine and the persistent doping s
1,064 likes, 237 comments - vadym____kolesnik on December 20, 2024: "I would like to express my concern and to advocate for the exclusion of Russia from the Olympic qualifying series. This request is grounded in two significant issues: the ongoing war in Ukraine and the persistent doping...www.instagram.com
Vadym's polite response to a trollish comment:I would like to express my concern and to advocate for the exclusion of Russia from the Olympic qualifying series. This request is grounded in two significant issues: the ongoing war in Ukraine and the persistent doping scandals involving Russian athletes.
Firstly, the war in Ukraine, initiated by Russia, has had devastating consequences, resulting in the loss of countless lives and widespread destruction. The international community has condemned these actions, and it is crucial that sports organizations like the International Skating Union take a stand against such aggression. Allowing Russia to participate in the Olympic qualifying series sends a contradictory message and undermines the principles of peace and unity that the Olympic Games represent.
Secondly, the history of doping scandals involving Russian athletes cannot be overlooked. Despite numerous warnings and sanctions, there have been multiple instances where Russian athletes have been found guilty of using performance-enhancing drugs. This not only tarnishes the integrity of the sport but also creates an unfair playing field for athletes from other countries who compete cleanly and fairly.
In case this post does not change anything, just want to remind all that acording to the rules that @isufigureskating has posted, all of these athletes should be prohibited from participating in the 2026 Olympic Qualification. #russiaterroiststate #betterwithoutthem #cleansport #figureskating #slavaukraine
ETA Nadiia Bashynska's comment: "I'm with you entirely... Thank you for your input.
Politics and figure skating are not intertwined in the USA or many other countries, unlike russia. russian athletes continue to support and promote russian war propaganda. I hope that isu will do their due diligence in vetting supposed neutral athletes!
Channel one is state controlled and has been called the official channel for war support. Isu bans any “implicit” support as well as explicit. Khudaiberdieva herself was in channel one cup! The official isu rules are almost entirely about guilt by association. It’s a sanctioned channel! Isu also demand Russian skaters know things like what has been sanctioned by United States Eu UN etc.One other thing that just occurred to me... Presuming RUS/BLR is not allowed back to international competition in the fall, every single AIN approved is going to be skating first in Milano-Cortina as they will have no WS points or ranking. I don't think that will hurt a team like Mishina/Galliamov since they are the reigning Olympic bronze medalists. It also probably wouldn't hurt Stepanova/Bukin if they're allowed to go, since they had such a high WR before the ban. The men and women, it could definitely hurt them skating that early.
And, I was misremembering the discussion about Russian dance teams on X earlier in the week. It's Khavronina whose dad is involved with the Russian military, so she & her partner are probably out. Khudaiberdieva's ex-husband was a producer at Channel 1 which isn't really enough to disqualify her based on the criteria the ISU has provided, I don't think.
Okaaaay. Just keep posting that over and over again and we'll find out eventually if you turn out to be right.Isu bans any “implicit” support as well as explicit. ... The official isu rules are almost entirely about guilt by association. ... Isu also demand Russian skaters know things like what has been sanctioned by United States Eu UN etc.
The thread title is so misleading!!
BTW, I decided not to modify my original thread title just to spite you.False. You didn’t read anything the isu said. Only the thread title which is totally divorced from what the isu said! Or a comment from someone who also didn’t read what the isu said. Any Russian skater who has participated in any state event is banned. Who does that leave! No one who has competed or probably even lived in Russia for over 3 years!
Circling back to this once again - really, the fact that the Figure Skating OQE is in Beijing is NOT related to this decision to allow RUS/BLR to attempt to qualify. It doesn't have anything to do with it being easier to travel to China than western countries. It doesn't have anything to do with the media control in China vs. the west.We don’t know who bid for the qualifying competition or not. It does seem rather convenient that Beijing was chosen - a country to which Russian and Belarusian skaters will have no issues travelling. Also much easier to control the media in China.
Circling back to this once again - really, the fact that the Figure Skating OQE is in Beijing is NOT related to this decision to allow RUS/BLR to attempt to qualify. It doesn't have anything to do with it being easier to travel to China than western countries. It doesn't have anything to do with the media control in China vs. the west.
How am I so certain of this?
Here is the list of OQEs where RUS/BLR athletes may attempt to qualify for Milano-Cortina in Short-Track and Speed Skating:
• Short Track:
o ISU Short Track World Tour – October 16-19, 2025 – Montreal, Canada
o ISU Short Track World Tour – October 23-26, 2025 – Salt Lake City, USA
o ISU Short Track World Tour – November 20-23, 2025 – Gdansk, Poland
o ISU Short Track World Tour – November 27-30, 2025 – Dordrecht, Netherlands
•Speed Skating:
o ISU World Cup Speed Skating – November 14-16, 2025 – Salt Lake City, USA
o ISU World Cup Speed Skating – November 21-23, 2025 – Calgary, Canada
o ISU World Cup Speed Skating – December 5-7, 2025 – Heerenveen, Netherlands
o ISU World Cup Speed Skating – December 12-14, 2025 – Hamar, Norway
The selection of Beijing for the FS OQE is NOT some "convenient" selection the ISU made with the knowledge they were heading down this AIN path, no matter how 'conspiracy theorist' you want to be about it. Surely, if that were the case then none of Canada, the USA, Poland, the Netherlands or Norway would have been designated for Short-Track and Speed Skating - unless you think the media is equally controlled in those five countries as it is in China, but that is probably a conversation that belongs in PI if so. And it's certainly not easy to get to Russia from the USA and vice versa, given that Naomi Lang said it's going to take something like 30 hours for her to get there. The lack of direct travel links to western Europe and North America from Russia is still very real and that's not even taking into consideration the challenges of receiving visas from some of the countries with designated OQEs in Short-Track and Speed Skating.
Well people are acting like there will be 3 pairs 3 dance teams 3 men and 3 women and Russia will be in team event and everything because of the thread title. It’s completely unimaginable based on the rules isu issued any Russians are eligible. Really I expect more applause for isu continued effort to destroy skating in RussiaOkaaaay. Just keep posting that over and over again and we'll find out eventually if you turn out to be right.
BTW, I decided not to modify my original thread title just to spite you.For the record, I did consider using "ISU decision concerning the participation of a limited number of Individual Neutral Athletes (AIN) from Russia & Belarus at Olympic Qualification Events under strict conditions" but, in the end, felt it was too long and unwieldy.
![]()
No, people are NOT. People are asking questions because they haven't bothered with reading the whole discussion thread - between @Sylvia and myself, we posted all of that information in the first two posts in this discussion.Well people are acting like there will be 3 pairs 3 dance teams 3 men and 3 women and Russia will be in team event and everything because of the thread title. It’s completely unimaginable based on the rules isu issued any Russians are eligible. Really I expect more applause for isu continued effort to destroy skating in Russia
Here is the thing. Channel One is a pro war rally almost 24/7. This is known to all. Channel one cup is a competition in a pro war rally environment.No, people are NOT. People are asking questions because they haven't bothered with reading the whole discussion thread - between @Sylvia and myself, we posted all of that information in the first two posts in this discussion.
The thread title is NOT misleading. There are a lot of questions as to what the ISU will consider to be "implicit" support for the war. There's enough grey area that the ISU could very well make it known, quietly, to the RFSF that any of their top athletes who have participated in the likes of the Channel 1 Cup are considered to be acting as propagandists for the state and supporting the war, regardless of whether those skaters are privately opposed to it.
My expectation is that the ISU/IOC are going to take a middle ground and view participation in events like Nationals or the Channel 1 Cup, or even shows/tours supported by government grants as okay, provided the skater in question has a clean media/social media profile with no overt support for the war or attendance at any pro-war rallies. I also think that skaters like Boikova/Kozlovskii and Tuktamysheva who immediately after the Tula show disavowed their participation in it are going to be fine.
Skaters who may run into trouble are ones like Stepanova/Bukin who attended Putin's speech to the Federal Assembly last February or who have been clear war supporters like Kondratiuk (as well as the retired ones like Tarasova/Morozov and Sinitsina/Katsalapov). Same with Khavronina, whose dad is affiliated with the Russian military and quite wealthy as a result.
With regard to Valieva - I suspect that any skaters who trained with Valieva before the WADA ban was announced are going to be okay provided they have not associated/trained with her since then. Skaters who have come out since the WADA ban to express support for her... They may have a tougher time being approved as that is, quite clearly, an explicit expression of support for someone who has a doping violation.
Additionally, any skaters who were under the care of the esteemed Dr. Shvetsky at any point in their career may have a tough time being approved seeing as he DID serve a WADA ban for his role in the 2008 Beijing rowers doping scandal. That could be quite problematic for Petrosian as she has been coached by Team Eteri for several years.
The ISU/IOC are going to have to tread a very careful line here on who is or is not approved because you can be certain that FS fans will provide receipts and hold them accountable. There's no amount of "they won't be allowed to participate in press conferences or go through the mixed zone" that is going to shield the ISU themselves from massive backlash if they let anyone in who is obviously supporting Putin and his war.
I guess we'll have to see just how serious the ISU/IOC is about what constitutes ineligibility per their rather broad yet vague criteria. You may be correct that none of the skaters who have competed in the last 3 years are eligible. I don't know that I agree with that assessment. If that was the case then why bother opening up ANY pathway at all?Here is the thing. Channel One is a pro war rally almost 24/7. This is known to all. Channel one cup is a competition in a pro war rally environment.
Also There should be no expectation yet whatsoever that any Russians will be eligible. It could be ruled that being at Russian nationals sponsored by known sanctioned companies voids eligibility! That being on Russias main channel supporting the war when it too is under sanction voids eligibility.
People posted such angry Angry comments. Why? There was no reason to believe based on what was written by isu that any skaters active in Russia the past 3 years will be eligible.
Was she? You listed team captains for 2023. Her ban was imposed by CAS on Jan 29, 2024, retroactively effective from Dec 25, 2021. I don't see how anyone who participated on her team in 2023 is going to find themselves rejected by the ISU/IOC for AIN status when no one knew the outcome of the CAS tribunal until nearly 11 months later.Valieva was captain of a team at the channel 1 cup and lots of the big names of Russian skating were on her team. This was after her ban! So two strikes
No one knows how many federations put in a bid for the OQE.And I thought I read here that the ISU had to extend the deadline for applying to the Olympic qualifying event, because they didn't have applicants. I didn't realize Beijing was a neutral choice among many applicants.
Maybe this has already been discussed somewhere - but the ISU is looking for a member country to host an Olympic Qualifying Event in the fall of 2025. Does this mean that the qualifying event will not be at Nebelhorn this time?
From Minutes of the 58th Ordinary Congress Phuket 2022 (p. 133)
Proposal No. 11. made by the ISU CouncilRule 100 paragraph 3.b) to make the Figure Skating Olympic Qualifying Competition an ISU Event.Fredi Schmid expressed the gratitude of the ISU to the Deutsche Eislauf-Union for organizing the Figure Skating Olympic Qualifying Competition over many years and for managing the organizational and financial challenges created by combining the Qualifying Competition with the regular International Competition. The Council felt it would be simpler and more efficient for the Qualifying Competition to be run as a separate ISU Event.The proposal was accepted by an obvious show of hands, with 2 votes against and 1 abstention.
ISU Communication No. 2665 (link now broken) originally was posted in this thread in September:
This is the new link (on the new ISU website) to ISU Communication No. 2665 - Application to host the ISU Figure Skating Olympic Qualifying Competition (August 27, 2024): https://isu-d8g8b4b7ece7aphs.a03.az...pdf/2665_FSK_OWG_Qual_Comp_20251731319276.pdf
Karen-W has updated the 2026 Olympics qualification info thread with this info: https://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/th...ting-qualification.111830/page-2#post-6703794
The isu did this to show how because of Putin all the skaters in Russia now are ineligible for the biggest most prestigious competitions in the world. Compete in war corrupted Russian nationals? Out. Compete in war corrupted entertainment show? Out. That they can never compete unless they leave Russia or Russia gets a new leader with new policies.I guess we'll have to see just how serious the ISU/IOC is about what constitutes ineligibility per their rather broad yet vague criteria. You may be correct that none of the skaters who have competed in the last 3 years are eligible. I don't know that I agree with that assessment. If that was the case then why bother opening up ANY pathway at all?
Was she? You listed team captains for 2023. Her ban was imposed by CAS on Jan 29, 2024, retroactively effective from Dec 25, 2021. I don't see how anyone who participated on her team in 2023 is going to find themselves rejected by the ISU/IOC for AIN status when no one knew the outcome of the CAS tribunal until nearly 11 months later.
No one knows how many federations put in a bid for the OQE.
Here are the relevant comments in the ISU Provisional Allotments thread -
There was also a discussion last October in SS - someone shared a X post/thread on the topic of the German fed not wanting to bid for the new OQE. So, we knew the German fed was out and that no one submitted a bid by the original Sept 20, 2024 deadline, so the ISU extended the deadline. Seems like it may not be much of a stretch to think the CFSA were the only ones to step up and submit a bid in the end.